Grey’s Anatomy is failing its audience in a significant way

"Why does Grey's Anatomy not have South-Asian doctors?" is a frequent question that used to pop up before 2018 on IMDb forums.

Shonda Rhimes has been applauded for overseeing an ever-growing cast of diverse characters, yet it took the show 14 seasons to hire two South-Asian doctors as regulars since it first aired in 2005.

Vikram Roy (Rushi Kita), an Indian-American, and Dahlia Qadri (Sophia Ali) of Pakistani descent, were the first South-Asian doctors in Seattle Grace/Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital to be introduced – in season 14 – among a fresh batch of medical interns.

rushi kota as vikram roy in bloodied scrubs, grey's anatomy season 14

ABC

While their roles weren't confined to stereotypical boxes with cringe-worthy accents, both were fired in the latest season, and fans have been left wondering how long they'll have to wait to see another brown character.

According to AAPI (American Association of Physicians of Indian origin), more than 80,000 practicing physicians in the United States are Indian or Indian American. They make up the largest non-Caucasian segment of the American medical community, where they account for one in every seven practicing doctors.

As one of the most popular medical shows of this generation – one with an otherwise strong history of representation – it is disappointing when such an important and obvious segment has been ignored for 14 seasons.

Some patients and nurses with South Asian heritage have popped up every now and then for some fleeting seconds, but the lack of visibility was, conversely, glaringly obvious to the community for 13 years.

anjul nigam as raj sen, grey's anatomy season 2

ABC

Dr Raj Sen (Anjul Nigam), a psychiatrist, has appeared in a couple of episodes for brief moments. Since the show strives to portray real lives of surgical interns and residents, it is as if the contribution of brown physicians in the US healthcare system is neither wanted nor appreciated, judging by the medical drama's neglect in terms of casting.

The show that launched Shonda Rhimes' production company Shondaland has arguably created iconic characters who are women of colour: Miranda Bailey (Chandra Wilson), Cristina Yang (Sandra Oh) and Callie Torres (Sara Ramirez). But as new interns emerged over the years, no South-Asian character received an equally powerful representation.

In contrast, ER, the longest-running medical drama since 1994 had Parminder Nagra in the main cast for six years playing Dr Neela Rasgotra. New Amsterdam has a more diverse pool of actors across a much smaller cast with Anupam Kher, a famous Indian actor, in a leading senior doctor role.

With each new Grey's season, viewers were let down because the number of South Asians entering the medical field has only skyrocketed in the last decade. A study from 2013 reveals that healthcare professionals of Indian origin make up 20% of students and faculty at American medical schools and hospitals – a number that has only gone up in recent years. It is so integral to the functioning of the medical community that one wouldn't expect to see brown roles in only a few guest spots.

One would argue there weren't enough South Asian actors in Hollywood a decade ago to draw from, but that simply isn't the case anymore. Mouzam Makkar was a lead on ABC's The Fix, a law drama. Sarayu Blue leads NBC sitcom I Feel Bad.

Diversity has been at the forefront of the Hollywood discourse in the last few years, but it shouldn't be confined to black and white. When certain minorities are excluded from the conversation, it is the same problem.

queen charlotte, bridgerton

Toni Anne Barson//Getty Images

It is understandable that Shonda Rhimes, as a producer, would want to focus on her own community, since most people of colour in the show are black actors, just as Mindy Kaling, for example, focuses on Indians. Yet, for a particular profession where involvement of the brown community is ubiquitous, it feels like a slap in the face to be ignored for so many years.

It is infuriating to see more white characters such as Cormac Hayes (Richard Flood) emerge in the latest season when the only two brown regulars in the history of the show have departed. One can only hope that in the future South Asians aren't reduced to occasional nurse roles and representation does not continue to move at a snail's pace. The series needs to correct its biggest mistake since its making.

Related Posts

19 Years Later, Grey’s Anatomy’s Most Important Character Is Holding the Show Back

Grey's Anatomy first struck a chord with audiences when it premiered in 2005 and has since seen a ton of acclaim and success. Though the hit medical…

This Dark Grey’s Anatomy Theory Will Make You Question Everything About the Last 20 Seasons

Grey's Anatomy is often celebrated as one of the best procedurals of the 21st century, boasting a ton of accolades and acclaim. When the team at Grey…

Grey’s Anatomy: Season 21, Episode 6, “Night Moves,” Recap & Spoilers

It's evening in Seattle when Season 21, Episode 6, "Night Moves," begins, and Owen Hunt and Teddy Altman are sitting down to a dinner out together —…

This Grey’s Anatomy Death Is Even More Heartbreaking 15 Years Later

Medical dramas tend to have a longer shelf life than a typical serialized television series, but Grey's Anatomy leaves them all in the dust. Created by Shonda…

Why Owen Hunt’s Sister Was Recast in Grey’s Anatomy

Presumably, it's almost impossible to find a single Grey's Anatomy character who has had simple and healthy family dynamics. There's always something hiding in the past of…

Mika’s Car Crash Breaks A Grey’s Anatomy Exit Trend For The Worse

Warning! SPOILERS about Grey’s Anatomy season 21, episode 6 ahead. The last moments of Grey's Anatomy season 21, episode 6 offered an insight into Mika’s potential exit…